Site Sponsor:

mcafee_logo.gif
line

Now Available:

Featured Resource:

line

Newsletter

Email Address:


line

Ask the Expert

Have a question for our resident expert? Email your questions to Dan or post a comment to the blog.

« Confusing Control with Security | Main | Tracing Ron Paul Spam »

MPAA Runs Into Its Own Copyright Infrigement Problems

The Motion Picture Association of America's toolkit for tracking copyright violators has run into its own copyright problems. The toolkit is based on Ubuntu Linux which is licensed under GPL. That open source license requires developers to make source code of their changes available to the public. Perhaps someone at MPAA didn't, er, how shall we say, read the copyright before using someone else software?

Ars Technica notes that MPAA was contracted by phone and email about the violation with no reply. Finally a take down order was sent to MPAA's ISP.

According to [Matthew] Garret [member of Ubuntu's technical board], several attempts were made to contact the MPAA before a takedown notice was sent directly to the ISP. "MPAA don't f*** with my s***," wrote Garret in a blog entry. "I did attempt to contact them by e-mail and phone before resorting to the more obnoxious behavior of contacting the ISP."

Although the MPAA's failure to comply with copyright law in this case is a delicious irony, it won't permanently prevent distribution of the antipiracy software toolkit. The MPAA will likely make the software available for download again after figuring out how to adhere to the stipulations imposed by the GPL. The most straightforward way to resolve the problem would be to post a notice next to the download link that provides contact information and affirms willingness to provide the source code upon request.

Perhaps the problem is that copyrights so complex even professionals in that field have trouble, or perhaps a sense of entitlement leads some of us to not bother to check copyrights, or perhaps, some people just don't care about other's copyrights.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.realtime-websecurity.com/type/mt-tb.cgi/550

Post a comment

(All comments are approved by site leader before appearing here. Thanks for commenting!)

line

Dan Sullivan's Bio:

Dan Sullivan is a systems architect with 20 years of IT experience that includes engagements in enterprise security, application design, and systems architecture. His experience includes a broad range of industries, including financial services, manufacturing, government, retail, gas and oil production, power generation, and education. Dan’s security-related project work has ranged from requirements analysis for enterprise information security to designing and implementing security for database applications and enterprise portals. Dan has written about information security and other enterprise information management topics for Business Security Advisor, DM Review, Intelligent Enterprise, and E-Business Advisor. You can contact Dan at: dan_sullivan@realtimepublishers.net